
When a Makarov is not a Makarov
by
alandp
on Sat 07 Oct 2006 10:08 PM CDT
This is not meant to be a comprehensive post about various 9x18mm pistols. It's just something I thought I'd throw together for those few readers of this blog who are less familiar with firearms than I am, inspired by some things seen at the gun show today.
Just because someone puts a tag on a pistol that says "Makarov," and it shoots 9x18mm ammunition, that does not mean it's actually a Makarov. Here is a picture of my Bulgarian Makarov which has Pearce replacement grips. The Makarov has a single grip screw in the back of the grips.
Note the elegant sweep of the frame leading up to the end of the barrel, the large oval base of the safety, the flat bottom of the magazine, and the more prominent sights. Okay, it's hard to see what I mean about the sights. Here's another Bulgie Mak which also has replacement grips.
Note also the round, serrated, but still somewhat difficult to access magazine release at the bottom right. Some Makarov owners will slip a metal key ring loop on the release to make access easier. Also note the large and easy to access slide release just above and to the right of the trigger.
This, on the other hand, is a FEG (Hungarian) PA-63. Note the curved bottom of the magazine, the less prominent sights, and the magazine release is completely different. Where is it, anyway? That button at the top of the grips? I'm not sure, but a quick study of these two photos will show that it is obviously not a Makarov. Also note the safety has a different shape, and the grip screw on the side of the grips. Where is the slide release?
This is a Polish P-64. On this one, note the very inelegant shape of the frame, the different shape of the safety, the curved extension of the magazine (and where is the mag release, again?), the grip screw on the side of the grips, the almost nonexistent sights, and a different hammer. All things that obviously set it apart from the Makarov. Note also the original stampings of "9MM" and "P-64," and that it looks like someone else later laser-etched the words "MAKAROV" and "X18" onto the slide. And once more, where is the slide release?
I write this post because today I saw more than one instance at the gun show where the tag attached to the pistol stated "MAKAROV," when it is obvious to anyone who owns one that they are not. The two examples I've shown here are not the only ones, they are just the ones I most frequently encounter.
These guns use 9x18mm ammo, just like the Makarov. However, there are no interchangeable parts, and that includes the magazines. These guns may be perfectly good guns. I don't have any personal experience with them, so I can't say. But if you are looking for a Makarov, you should know that these are not Makarovs just because they use the same ammo and a seller says they are.
All but the first picture are from
makarov.com, where you can find plenty of information about Makarovs and other pistols that use 9x18mm ammunition.